Litigation
The attorneys in Gould & Ratner’s Litigation Practice serve clients across the country, handling complex commercial matters for public companies, including those in the Fortune 500, as well as complicated business matters for the firm’s traditional client base of middle-market, closely held and family businesses.
Litigators for Business
Our litigators are highly skilled and experienced trial lawyers, practical and bottom-line oriented, yet as tough as a client wants or needs them to be, whether in state or federal court or before an administrative agency. For clients seeking other dispute resolution alternatives, our attorneys routinely appear before court-appointed and privately selected arbitrators and mediators.
Clients ask us to appear in the boardroom as well as in the courtroom because our trial lawyers are also business lawyers – professionals who understand that litigation can be an important tool for achieving a client’s business goals, but is not an end that is always desired. The firm’s litigation team does not just find a solution for a particular problem and then disappear once the matter has been resolved.
Clients seek out our litigation group attorneys to represent their ongoing business legal needs, such as adjusting certain business practices after a dispute has been settled or advising on preventative measures that can avoid litigation. Our clients also look to us to provide recommendations on how various dispute resolution alternatives can be used effectively and economically.
Diverse Experience
Our commercial litigation experience includes representing clients in a wide variety of matters, with significant focus on:
- Corporate, partnership, closely held business and securities litigation
- Products liability and mass tort
- Real estate litigation
- Construction litigation
- Employment litigation
- Intellectual property
- Environmental litigation
- Technology and e-commerce itigation
- Creditors’ rights and bankruptcy litigation
- Product distribution litigation
- Class actions
- Tax litigation
Appeals
Our experience also extends beyond the trial level, as is evidenced by the group’s extensive record of appellate advocacy. The firm’s litigation partners are sought out to handle difficult appeals and have argued cases before a number of appellate forums, including the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals, and the Illinois Appellate and Supreme Courts.
Representative Matters
- Represented video display manufacturer in dispute concerning development of 3-D technology for use in the gaming industry.
- Obtained affirmance of trial court’s refusal to pierce the veil of general partner in connection with dispute over multimillion-dollar real estate development, strengthening Illinois protection for corporate entities.
- Represented newspaper during federal jury trial against defamation claim stemming from investigation of pyramid scheme.
- Represented investment bank against securities fraud and ERISA claims stemming from the collapse of Global Crossing.
- Represented regional bank in dispute concerning a restrictive covenant affecting the development of an outparcel property. Successfully obtained release of restrictive covenant for nominal consideration pre-trial.
- Represented national chain of retail optical stores in a dispute with Chicago-based developer seeking to alter client’s premises to facilitate substantial renovation/redevelopment of downtown Chicago office building. Successfully obtained both preliminary and permanent injunctive relief enjoining developer from infringing on tenant’s leasehold interest and significant rent concessions from developer to obtain future cooperation with redevelopment efforts.
- Represented mining concern in dispute over disbursement of $5 million held under the terms of an escrow agreement executed in connection with a settlement of a condemnation action
- Represented numerous condominium developers in disputes with independent condominium boards concerning allegations of construction defects, underfunded capital reserve accounts and underpayment of assessments before turnover to association. Also represented numerous condominium developers in partnership disputes concerning construction cost overruns and breaches of fiduciary duties.
- Represented numerous sellers and buyers in lawsuits seeking specific performance.
- Represented several downtown office building owners in numerous lawsuits filed by current and former tenants disputing the allocation and calculation of expenses and real estate taxes.
- Represented landowners from neighboring landowner’s lawsuit alleging the existence of a prescriptive easement.
- Obtained defense summary judgment for tractor-trailer manufacturer in vehicle accident product liability claim.
- Trial counsel in federal court suit obtaining permanent injunction in ADA and zoning case against municipality.
- Trial counsel in Minneapolis jury trial in dispute between partners in real estate investment venture.
- Obtained multimillion-dollar settlement for a family trust in breach of fiduciary duty suit against institutional trustee.
- Obtained defense summary judgment in favor of tractor-trailer manufacturer in product liability and wrongful death claim arising from a rear-end highway collision.
- Trial counsel in federal court action defending newspaper in multimillion-dollar defamation action.
- Trial counsel in Cook County Circuit Court action for contractual indemnity for losses arising from construction site accident.
- Trial counsel obtaining defense judgment in federal court business fraud lawsuit arising from $14-million sale of diesel utility-grade generators.
- Trial counsel in a Cook County Circuit Court jury case representing a steel manufacturer, involving alleged defects in steel beams sold for use in a nuclear power plant.
- Lead counsel in numerous arbitrations, including defending an Illinois coal producer in several arbitrations brought by a public utility under a long-term supply agreement.
- Represented a municipality in a suit against its former insurance claims administrator and its auditing firm for failing to detect a multimillion-dollar fraud regarding the management of its self-insurance program. Obtained a favorable settlement for the municipality.
- Represented a manufacturer in a trade secrets action against a competitor who obtained the client’s designs through a common supplier. Obtained a favorable judgment at trial.
- Won a multimillion-dollar arbitration victory for a pharmaceutical company. The arbitration, conducted in New York City, concerned a license and development agreement for a drug to be administered to feedlot cattle using a microsphere and time-release technology. The arbitration involved substantial technical expert testimony concerning pharmaceutical bioequivalence and drug formulation issues, and whether all commercially reasonable steps to obtain FDA approval were taken.
- Representation of national financial services company tendering defense and pursuing financial loss coverage under PL/D&O and excess policies of claims alleging misconduct in provision of consumer mortgages.
- Representation of global consumer goods manufacturer asserting product liability and contribution claims arising out of personal injury during industrial accident, including recovery of million-dollar judgment at trial.
- Representation of national manufacturer of transportation equipment in products liability and personal injury lawsuit in which plaintiff sought millions of dollars.
- Representation of international motor sports entity in putative class action alleging variety of contract and tort claims in connection with racing event.
- Representation of insurance and investment companies in internal investigations regarding alleged bid rigging, business steering, receipt of improper incentives, fraud, and violation of anti-kickback laws.
- Representation of multi-line business and personal insurance agency in expansive asbestos litigation claims pending against its insured, a manufacturer of resilient sheet and tile flooring.
- Representation of worldwide manufacturer of farm and construction equipment against various product defect lawsuits.
- Representation of international medical technology company conducting internal investigation involving allegations of financial misconduct and fraud, including violation of anti-kickback laws.
- Representation of various firms, businesses, and individuals responding to subpoenas, governmental letter requests, and other pre-suit and third-party discovery for information, documents, and witness testimony.
- Representation of a local business prosecuting discriminatory zoning claims against municipality in five-day federal trial.
- Representation of beneficiaries of highly-contested estate involving closely-held family businesses and complex financing issues requiring coordination with international financial lending institution.
- Representation of a leading private food manufacturer enforcing non-compete agreement with former employees.
- Representation of equipment manufacturer pursuing claims for breach of purchase agreement and non-compete agreement and defending antitrust counterclaims.
- Representation of top executive of global financial and investment firm pursuing damages due to breach of employment contract, including million-dollar recovery in settlement.
- Representation of global commercial services provider responding to EEOC investigation and defending against civil law suit alleging Title VII discrimination, sexual harassment, and retaliation claims
- Representation of baked goods manufacturer specializing in custom formulations defending against conversion claims and prosecuting breach of contract and violations of trade secret and intellectual property laws.
- Representation of leading developer of custom-engineered and application specific technology products and solutions defending patent infringement claims quad small form factor pluggable (QSFP+) transceivers and adapters.
- Representation of financial institutions investigating potential infringement claims and negotiating and drafting services contracts relating to intellectual
property and infringement indemnifications.
- Representation of an international commercial real estate service firm defending breach of contract, professional malpractice, breach of fiduciary duty and negligent misrepresentation claims in arbitration.
- Representation of commercial real estate services firm defending claims for breach of contract, breach of fiduciary and statutory duties, and professional negligence on expedited, full-discovery bases in AAA arbitration.
- Representation of former top executive of billion-dollar commercial real-estate investment management firm prosecuting treatment of income against Internal Revenue Service.
- Representation of legal and tax professionals prosecuting and defending against claims involving development and sale of tax preparation services and strategies.
- Represented a large real estate developer in an action against an auditing firm for failing to detect a multimillion-dollar embezzlement by the developer’s bookkeeper. Despite the fact that no audit or attestation level services were performed, obtained a seven-figure recovery at trial based upon the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants’ Management Advisory Standards (which had seldom been used to impute liability in litigation matters prior to that time).
- Lead counsel representing a general contractor in negotiating and reviewing the contract documents in connection with a $118-million, 1-million-square-foot convention center project in Seattle. At the conclusion of the construction contracts, prepared claim that was developed as a result of design deficiencies and schedule impacts, resulting in numerous change orders. The settlement structure for the claim totaled $60 million and was agreed to at a mediation hearing before litigation.
- Lead trial counsel for owner in litigation involving, among other things, responsibility for construction defects at a multimillion-dollar senior development. Successful in developing a litigation strategy that lead to the settlement of all of the litigation claims on terms acceptable to the owner during the trial.
- Lead trial counsel for a contractor in successful litigation with a public utility responsible for the contamination of a coal gasification site; obtained a multimillion-dollar award.
- Represented a large real estate developer who entered into a store lease with one of the largest clothing designers in the world for that designer to develop a Chicago flagship store. After incurring substantial construction and other expenses to ready the premises, the client was notified by the designer that it would no longer rent the space. A declaratory action was initiated in federal court and a substantial verdict was rendered in favor of our client. That verdict on appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit was preserved and the matter settled for a multimillion-dollar amount.
- Lead counsel representing a financial institution in an investigation of the conduct of a board member; developed a plan for the institution that would both resolve the problem with the existing board member and prevent the conduct from occurring in the future with other board members.
- Lead trial counsel in representation of a California corporation in a trademark dispute over the use of certain paintings that were silk-screened and sold in large numbers by a national discount chain. Achieved injunctive relief and eventually reached a settlement that provided for a disgorgement of the profits wrongfully made by the defendant’s misuse of the client’s product.
- Represented a municipality in a suit against its former auditing firm for failing to detect a multimillion-dollar fraud regarding the management of its self-insurance program. Obtained a favorable settlement for the municipality.
- Successfully argued before the Illinois Supreme Court the issue of how to treat Illinois Consumer Fraud Act claims, when such claims are asserted as part of a class action complaint involving a nationwide class.
- Represented purchaser/homeowner in dispute involving a developer/vendor’s fraudulent sale of property.
- Represented former beneficiaries of a trust in action against an institutional trustee for breach of trust.
- Successfully represented a minority owner of an emerging technology business in a partner dispute leading to settlement through mediation.
- Successfully represented a Chinese tool-and-die manufacturer in a multimillion-dollar dispute with the U.S. division of a global equipment company.
Publications
- CARES Act Expands SBA Loan Programs to Offer Relief for Small Businesses During the COVID-19 Pandemic, March 30, 2020
- COVID-19 and Commercial Disputes: Some Practical Considerations, March 17, 2020
- Supreme Example: An Interview with the Chief Justice of the Michigan Supreme Court, American Bar Association, Litigation Section, February 20, 2020
- The Business Courts Benchbook: Procedures and Best Practices in Business and Commercial Cases, American Bar Association, November 19, 2019
- Here Today, Gone Tomorrow? Rules Changing How Endangered Species Act is Applied, August 13, 2019
- The Importance of Advancement in Corporate Formation and Litigation Strategy , July 31, 2019
- The Long Arm of Delaware’s LLC Act May Impact Your Illinois LLC’s Dissolution, July 31, 2019
- Coming Soon: Key 2019 Canadian Trademark Change Drops Proof of Use Requirement, May 24, 2019
- Time To Rethink Mandatory Arbitration Agreements? U.S. Supreme Court Rules Class Action Waivers Are Legal, HumanResourcesLawBlog.com, May 25, 2018
- Judge Strikes Down New DOL Rule on Overtime and White Collar Exemption, HumanResourcesLawBlog.com, September 6, 2017
- High Court Rulings Hinder Patent Enforcement, Law360.com, May 30, 2017
- Arbitration and “Appellate” Review: Competing Legal Principles, American Bar Association, May 2017
- Supreme Court Ruling in Samsung v. Apple Decision Opens Door for Apportionment of Patent Damages, Inside Counsel, December 9, 2016
- Franchisor Is Not "Lovin' It", April 30, 2016
- Identifying "Acts of God" in the Age of Climate Change and Political Upheaval, Construction Update, April 2016
- Would Your Company's Non-Compete Survive a Challenge in Court?, Employment e-lert, March 2016
- Business Law Section Diversity Clerkship Program: Exposing Minority Students to Careers in Business Law, Business Law Today, October 2013
- Spouse of Undocumented Alien Fails to State Discrimination Claim, American Bar Association, Litigation Section News & Developments, January 2013
- Recent Developments in the Enforcement of Restrictive Covenants, Illinois Banker, April 2012
- Indemnity for One's Own Negligence or Strict Liabilities, The Globe, June 2011
- Dispute Resolution Issues in Connection With Price Adjustments, GR Review, July 2010
- Picking Off the Class Plaintiff: The Illinois Appellate Court's Latest Word on Settling With the Plaintiff Prior to Class Certification, GR Review, October 2008
- How Not to Purchase an Outparcel, Shopping Center Business, November 2007
- Review of Arbitration Awards: Are They Still "Final" in the First Appellate District?, GR Review, October 2007
- No Relief Behind the Counter: Does Federal Law Protect a Pharmacist Who Refuses to Fill Birth Control Prescriptions?, Employment e-lert, August 2007
- Judicial Review of International Arbitral Awards: Preserving Independence in International Commercial Arbitration, Marquette Law Review, January 1997
News
- Corporate Practice Welcomes Christopher J. Rog, February 24, 2020
- Eight Gould & Ratner Lawyers Earn Illinois Super Lawyers, Rising Stars Designation for 2020, January 30, 2020
- Litigation Practice Welcomes Emily Wessel Farr, GR Media Release, November 18, 2019
- Jillian Molz Discusses New Illinois Laws Protecting Job Applicants, SHRM, August 13, 2019
- Karin O’Connell Appointed Vice Chair of Membership for ABA’s Endangered Species Committee, July 30, 2019
- Jessica Lingertat and David Michael Named to Crain’s “2019 Notable Gen X Leaders in Law” List, Crain's Chicago Business, May 30, 2019
- Gould & Ratner Lawyer Coaches Loyola Moot Court Team to Victory, Again, Chicago Daily Law Bulletin, November 19, 2018
- Jillian Molz Joins Gould & Ratner's Litigation Practice, GR Media Release, November 2018
- Vanessa Tiradentes Named Partner at Gould & Ratner, July 2018
- Gould & Ratner Lawyer Coaches Loyola Moot Court Team to Victory, Chicago Daily Law Bulletin, November 8, 2017
- Justin Hanson Joins Gould & Ratner, October 2017
- 3 Takeaways From 7th Circ.'s Watershed Gay Bias Ruling, Law360, April 5, 2017
- EEO-1 Pay Reporting, Overtime Rule May Be Repealed Following Trump Order, SHRM.com, March 20, 2017
- Bill to End Deference to Regulatory Interpretations Could Impact USPTO, Law360.com, January 20, 2017
- Vanessa Tiradentes Joins Gould & Ratner, GR Media Release, August 24, 2016
Events
- Eric Sparks and Vanessa Tiradentes Presented at the Illinois Institute for Continuing Legal Education’s Trial Advocacy for Civil Litigators Program, October 17, 2019
- Vanessa Tiradentes Presented at the 2019 ABA Business Law Section Annual Meeting, September 12, 2019
- Karin O'Connell Discussed the Endangered Species Act in ABA SEER Essentials Webinar, August 27, 2019
- #MeToo Era Tips for In House & Outside Counsel Success, March 20, 2019
- Recent Developments in the Delaware Chancery Court and the New York State Supreme Court Commercial Division, July 26, 2018
- Valuation and Damages in Business Divorce Cases, November 17, 2017
- Vanessa Tiradentes was a speaker on a Meritas Capability Webinar, June 11, 2015
